Dealing with Variations: A Contractor’s Guide to Handling Superintendent Refusals

As a contractor, navigating the complexities of construction contracts is an integral part of your role. One common challenge that contractors often encounter is when the superintendent refuses to grant variations in construction contracts. This can be a frustrating and potentially costly situation, but there are steps and strategies you can employ to effectively handle this scenario.

Understanding the Situation

Before taking any action, it’s crucial to understand the reasons behind the superintendent’s refusal. Variations in construction contracts typically arise due to unforeseen circumstances, changes in project specifications, or client requests. The superintendent’s reluctance to grant variations could stem from concerns about project timelines, budget constraints, or potential impact on the overall project scope.

Steps to Address the Refusal

When faced with a refusal of variations in construction contracts, consider the following steps to effectively address the situation:

  1. Review Contractual Terms: Thoroughly review the contractual terms related to variations. Understanding your rights and obligations as outlined in the contract is essential when addressing the refusal.
  2. Communicate Clearly: Initiate a clear and professional dialogue with the superintendent. Express your concerns and provide detailed justifications for the variations, including any relevant documentation or evidence to support your case.
  3. Seek Compromise: Explore opportunities for compromise. Propose alternative solutions that address the concerns raised by the superintendent while still accommodating the necessary variations.
  4. Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all communications, including emails, letters, and meeting minutes. This documentation will serve as valuable evidence in the event of further dispute resolution.
  5. Consult Legal Counsel: If the situation remains unresolved, consider seeking legal counsel to assess your options and provide guidance on how to proceed within the parameters of the contract and applicable laws.

Strategies for Mitigation

In addition to the specific steps outlined, consider employing the following strategies to mitigate the impact of a refusal of variations:

  • Proactive Risk Assessment: Anticipate potential variations early in the project and conduct thorough risk assessments to identify and address potential obstacles.
  • Clear Change Management Process: Establish a clear and transparent change management process within the project to streamline the handling of variations and ensure all stakeholders are informed and involved.
  • Build Strong Relationships: Cultivate strong, professional relationships with the superintendent and other key stakeholders. Effective communication and a collaborative approach can facilitate smoother resolution of issues.

Example Scenario

Consider a scenario where the superintendent refuses a variation due to concerns about project delays. In this situation, you could proactively propose a revised timeline that minimizes the impact on the overall schedule while still accommodating the necessary variation. By providing a detailed plan outlining how the variation can be implemented without significant disruption, you demonstrate your commitment to addressing the superintendent’s concerns while meeting the project’s requirements.


Dealing with a refusal of variations in construction contracts requires careful consideration, clear communication, and a proactive approach to resolution. By understanding the reasons behind the refusal, taking specific steps to address the situation, and implementing mitigation strategies, contractors can navigate this challenging scenario while minimizing potential disruptions to the project.

Remember, each situation is unique, and seeking professional advice when dealing with contractual disputes is essential to ensure that your actions align with legal and contractual requirements.

Navigating challenges in construction contracts is an ongoing process, and by approaching these scenarios with professionalism and diligence, contractors can effectively manage and resolve disputes, ultimately contributing to successful project outcomes.

Discover more from CMGuide

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue Reading

Scroll to Top