Contract Administration

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Dispute Boards, Project Management

The Delays We Cause Ourselves: Land, Permits and Utilities on Public Infrastructure Projects

By Dr Samer Skaik

On a large proportion of internationally financed infrastructure projects, the single biggest source of delay is not the contractor. It is the employer’s own inability to hand over the site.

Land that has not been acquired. Households that have not been resettled. A right of way that runs through three private holdings and a cemetery. Electricity poles, water mains and fibre that belong to state-owned utilities with no contractual relationship to the project and no particular urgency about it. An environmental clearance sitting with a regulator that answers to a different minister. Building permits from a municipality that was not consulted during design.

None of this appears in the contractor’s risk register, because none of it was ever the contractor’s to carry. Under the standard forms including FIDIC these are employer obligations, squarely and unambiguously. The contract requires the employer to give the contractor the right of access to and possession of the site, and where it fails to do so within the time required, the contractor is entitled to time and money.

Everyone involved knows this. And yet I have read many project documents in which the delay is described in the passive voice — access was not available, the site could not be handed over — as though it happened weather-like, to nobody in particular. …

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Dispute Boards, Project Management

The Engineer Who Cannot Decide: Contract Administration Inside a Government Approval Chain

B Dr Samer Skaik

There is a moment in project meetings that anyone who works on public infrastructure will recognise.

A question is put to the engineer. It is a fair question, within the engineer’s remit, and the answer is not especially difficult. And before answering, the engineer glances at the employer’s representative sitting across the table.

It lasts less than a second and everybody in the room sees it. The contractor sees it and files it away. The engineer’s own team sees it. And what it communicates is that the person the contract designates as the impartial administrator of this contract is, in practice, checking.

I do not raise this to criticise the engineers involved, most of whom are experienced professionals in an impossible position. I raise it because it is a structural problem specific to public employers, the contract does not solve it, and it is the origin of a startling number of the disputes I see. …

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Project Management

The Suspension That Never Ends: The 84-Day Clock and the Choice at the End of It

By Dr Samer Skaik

Suspension is the most under-used and most abused provision in the FIDIC time clauses, and it manages to be both at once for the same reason: it looks like a neutral administrative step and it is not.

The power itself is broad. The Engineer may instruct the Contractor to suspend progress of part or all of the Works, and under the 1999 wording is not obliged to give a reason. The Contractor must then protect, store and secure whatever has been suspended. In exchange, where the suspension is not attributable to the Contractor, it is entitled to an extension of time and to its Cost, with the 2017 edition treating the profit element more generously than its predecessor.

That is the clause. What makes it interesting is what happens when a suspension stops being an event and becomes a condition. …

Contract Administration, Dispute Boards, Project Management

The Board You Keep or the Board You Call: A Choice Made Long Before Anyone Argues

By Dr Samer Skaik

There is a box in the contract data of every works contract that gets filled in by someone who will never have to live with the consequences.

It is usually completed late in the tender preparation, often by a procurement officer working through a template under time pressure, sometimes by copying whatever was in the last one. It determines whether the project will have a dispute board sitting alongside it from the beginning, or whether one will be assembled at some future moment when things have gone wrong.

I have asked a number of public officials who made that decision on their project. In most cases the honest answer is that nobody made it. It was inherited. …

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Project Management

Telling a Contractor to Speed Up: The Instruction Employers Keep Getting Wrong

By Dr Samer Skaik

A project falls behind. The Employer becomes anxious. Somebody suggests that the Engineer should instruct the Contractor to accelerate, and a letter goes out.

What happens next depends entirely on a distinction that is rarely drawn at the time the letter is written, and the cost of getting it wrong runs in both directions. I have seen Employers believe they had purchased acceleration when they had bought nothing at all, and I have seen Contractors treat a routine progress instruction as a blank cheque and spend accordingly.

The provision at the centre of this is Sub-Clause 8.6 in the 1999 editions, renumbered 8.7 in 2017. It is worth being precise about what it does, because it is almost the opposite of what people assume. …

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Dispute Boards, Project Management

What Does a Dispute Board Actually Cost? A Straight Answer for Public Employers

By Dr Samer Skaik

Of all the questions I get asked by public sector clients, this is the one that arrives most often by private message rather than in the meeting.

People are slightly embarrassed to ask it. There is a sense that enquiring about the cost of a dispute mechanism is somehow unserious, or that it reveals you have not read something you should have read. So the question gets asked quietly, usually after the formal session has ended, and it is almost always phrased the same way: what does one of these actually cost us?

It is an entirely reasonable question and I wish more people asked it earlier and out loud. A project manager who cannot answer it cannot get the budget line approved, and a budget line that is not approved is one of the most common reasons a board never gets appointed at all. So let me try to answer it plainly. …

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Dispute Boards, Project Management

When the Banks moved onto FIDIC 2017: What Public Employers Inherited With the New Contract

By Dr Samer Skaik

A few years ago I sat in a workshop with the contract management team of a national roads agency. They were good at their jobs. Several of them had been administering donor-funded works contracts for well over a decade, and between them they had probably handled more claims than some law firms see in a generation.

About an hour in, one of the senior engineers said something that stopped the room. He said: we have been running this contract the way we ran the last four, and I am starting to think it is not the same contract.

He was right. It was not. …

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Dispute Boards, Project Management

The Programme Nobody Agreed To: Sub-Clause 8.3 and What Silence Actually Means

By Dr Samer Skaik

Ask three people on a FIDIC project what status the programme has, and you will usually get three answers.

The planner thinks it is a management tool. The contractor’s commercial manager thinks it is the baseline against which every delay claim will eventually be measured. And the Engineer, if pressed, will often say that it was never approved, which is a curious thing to say about a document the whole project has been working to for two years.

All three are partly right, and the confusion is not their fault. Sub-Clause 8.3 is one of the shortest provisions in the contract carrying one of the heaviest practical loads, and it does not answer the question everyone actually wants answered: is this thing binding? …

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Dispute Boards, Project Management

The First Four Weeks: How Public Infrastructure Employers Set a Project Up to Avoid Disputes

 

By Dr Samer Skaik

The call usually comes about eighteen months in.

Someone from an implementing agency, often a project manager who has inherited the file from a predecessor, explains that things have gone badly wrong. The ground turned out differently from the investigation report. The utility diversions never happened. The contractor has submitted a claim with a number in it large enough that it has now been seen by people several floors above the project office. And somewhere in the conversation comes the question I have learned to brace for: we think the contract requires us to have a dispute board — how quickly can one be set up? …

Construction Law, Contract Administration

Risk Allocation Under FIDIC: Employer’s Risks versus Contractor’s Risks in Clause 17

Every FIDIC contract is, at its core, a risk allocation instrument dressed up in construction terminology. Clause 17 is where that allocation is made explicit, dividing the universe of things that can go wrong on a project into two camps: risks the Contractor bears because it priced them, insured them, or is simply best placed to manage them, and risks the Employer bears because no reasonable contractor could have priced or controlled them. Getting this distinction wrong at tender stage, or misapplying it during the works, is one of the most common sources of disputes on international projects.

…

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Dispute Boards, Project Management

Parties’ Strategies for Selecting High-Performance Dispute Boards

In construction projects, the effectiveness of a Dispute Adjudicaiton Board (DB)—or Dispute Avoidance & Adjudication Board (DAAB)—is often determined long before the first project site meeting takes place. The process of appointing board members is a critical phase, acting as the foundation for how effectively a project will manage disagreements and maintain progress.

…

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Dispute Boards, Project Management

How to nominate a dispute board member (DAAB) under FIDIC contracts?

Disputes are almost a given in international construction projects. That’s why the FIDIC contracts include a smart system for resolving them quickly and fairly through Dispute Avoidance/Adjudication Boards, or DAABs. One of the most talked-about resources in this area is the FIDIC President’s List of Approved Dispute Adjudicators — basically a go-to directory of well-respected experts.

If you’re an employer, contractor, engineer, or legal advisor working on FIDIC-based projects, knowing how this list works — and how flexible the appointment process really is — can save you a lot of time, money, and headaches. In this guide, we’ll walk you through the key points in plain language. …

Scroll to Top