Project Organization Types
The way projects are structured is directly related to the way the entire organization is structured. There are three major organization structures to manage work and people. …
The way projects are structured is directly related to the way the entire organization is structured. There are three major organization structures to manage work and people. …
Sometimes the project manager can get too comfortable (or too uncomfortable) in how the project is progressing. In many cases, it makes sense to have an outside party come in to evaluate the project management processes being utilized and double-check that the project is progressing as expected. This “outside party” could be any qualified person outside of the project manager. …
Use a Project Audit to Validate Your Schedule and Budget StatusRead More »
by Dennis Brand
As a general principle, a company cannot subcontract any part of their scope of works without the employer’s consent unless the contract expressly states otherwise. …
Michelle Nelson, partner, Pinsent Masons, says it is worth examining five common traps before plunging into construction in Dubai.
Let’s examine some of the potentially troublesome issues which contractors face regularly in the Dubai construction market. In preparing this article I have highlighted five issues which we are asked to advise contractors on regularly. …
By: Antonios Dimitracopoulos
Arbitration is almost by default the standard dispute resolution mode built into construction contracts. But is it always as efficient and suitable for the purpose it is meant to be? Or is it so only under certain conditions which, if left uncared for, can result in an erosion of what was meant to be an improvement to litigation. …
By Samer H Skaik
Sometimes, clients face difficulty to procure projects due to absence of competitors. The risk of how to secure value for money is extremely high when dealing with one single contractor to quote and execute the works. This article gives significant guidelines for which client can follow to minimize such risk and achieve value for money:
1. Give priority for traditional accelerated procurement route:
By adopting this route, the contractor is appointed early during the design stage based on partial information made available by Design team. Due to early involvement in design stage, the contractor can add a significant input to the design and improve the billability since he is the only specialist who can carry out such works. This involvement will somehow ensure value for money.
Design should be sound, efficient and integrated to avoid variations risks in construction stage which will affect the price certainty due to possible design errors, additions and omissions. Client advisor needs to supervise the design development precisely as first step to ensure value for money ad reasonable cost certainty. On the other hand, budget estimate should be done by the consultant upon the completion of brief design based on historical data. It should typically have an accuracy of 10% to 15% (Keith, 2008).
3. Go for single tendering process: (Negotiated – No competition)
In such scenario, the client should go for single tendering in which it approaches the contractor directly to quote for the project. Negotiation skills must be mainly adopted to ensure the price is as minimal as possible to secure the value for money. This process does require experienced clients and consultants to have influence on the contractor to reduce his price (Turner, 1997).
Effective procedures during the single tendering process must be adopted with the contractor to reach to a satisfactory level prior to sign the contract as follows (Marsh, 2000):
4. Start the negotiation procedures to secure the value for money:
There are basically two methods to negotiate the price (Marsh, 2000):
ü Simple Comparison Measures:
In this method, some priced items of the contractor are compared with similar ones known to the consultant from previous recent competitive tender. In this project, the difficulty arises when it seems to be impossible to compare any of the items on apple to apple basis, since the nature of the whole project is unique.
ü Alternative method:
The contractor will be instructed to submit detailed break down of his firm prices separating out the markup and preliminaries from the dry cost. The dry cost will be separated into labour, material, equipment and vendors with precise quantities of each item.
Alternative method seems more suitable to be adopted in this project and further discussion of costs and prices can commence as follows (Marsh, 2000:
5. Improve price certainty by transferring risks:
It is recommended to transfer the potential risks such as the price escalation risk and bad weather to the contractor to secure price certainty. This can be achieved by appropriate wording in the contract clauses. The criteria is to transfer the risks to party best able to handle it which comes in line with the objective of value for money as well. However, it is unwise to transfer a risk to the contractor if it is difficult to assess (Mudoch & Hughes, 2000).
6. Appoint the same designer to supervise the construction stage:
Consultant who made the design is recommended to play supervising and monitoring role during construction to ensure the high quality and smooth progress. He will be effective in making the sound decisions in case of any design query raised during construction.
7. Suggest target cost contract as an alternative approach:
It is possible that the contractor objects to go for the lump sum contract following the above procedures. In this case the client can suggest going for cost plus contract incorporating target cost and guaranteed maximum price. Target cost will be derived from the pre-contract budget and cost plan. Maximum value for money can be secured by the project team by trying to reduce the costs as far below the target cost as possible (Morledge, Smith, Kashiwagi, 2006). Moreover, cost certainty can be reasonable in presence of realistic GMP. This approach can be effective by applying share gain/pain policy and open book accounts.
References:
1. Keith, P. (2008), Construction Cost Management: Learning from Case Studies, Routledge
2. Turner, A. (1997), Building procurement, (second edition), Palgrave macmillan, London.
3. Marsh, P. (2000), Contracting for Engineering and Construction Projects,(Fifth Edition), Gower Publishing.
4. Morledge, R., Smith, A. and Kashiwagi D. (2006), Building procurement, Blackwell Publishing, Oxford.
5. Mudoch, J., Hughes, W. (2000), Construction contracts law and management, third edition, Spon press, New York.
by Kristine Kalnina
Kristine Kalnina, Bin Shabib and Associates.Looking at any of the impressive structures shaping Dubai’s skyline, one may see just glass and steel as the main constituent components. But all projects stem from an idea before they become tangible objects and that idea heavily depends on first building successful relationships. …
By Hamish Macdonald
In the first place, DABs are not intended to replace arbitration or litigation but are to be considered as part of a multi-tiered dispute resolution process. The use of a DAB has been described as an early and intermediary step directed at avoiding the need to resort to other more expensive and more time-consuming procedures such as arbitration or litigation. …
When you manage the schedule and budget, you normally do not need to be accurate to the minute or to the dollar. You also do not want make all kinds of proactive changes if your project is a day over deadline one week and a day ahead of schedule the next. …
It is hard to define product or service quality at a high level because the term “quality” is nebulous and means different things to different people. You must take the time to define the lower-level characteristics of quality for each specific service or deliverable. If you want to ensure that a service or product meets the customer’s expectations of quality, you have to understand the underlying characteristics of quality. …
Understand the Characteristics of Quality for Your ProjectRead More »
In some procurement contexts, the choice of contract may be determined by external factors, such as requirements of the funder. For example the World Bank now require the FIDIC forms of contract to be used on projects of over £6 million, and it appears as if the NEC form may be the preferred choice for the Olympic construction programme. In such cases the form to be used will have been selected before the Architect and other consultants are appointed. …
Advising clients on the appropriate form of contractRead More »
The process of creating the Project Charter, schedule and budget may take a long time and may be very complicated. Therefore, the work should not be left unorganized, for the same reasons that you are building the schedule for the project to begin with. Immediately after being assigned, the project manager should create a short-term schedule to plan and guide the initial activities. …
Create a Short-Term Schedule to Guide the Definition and Planning ProcessesRead More »