Statutory Adjudication

Exploring the challenges relating to the jurisdiction of statutory adjudicators

By Dr Samer Skaik

The jurisdiction of adjudicators is a critical element in the adjudication process for construction disputes. Adjudicators derive their authority by accepting referrals from an appointing authority, which hinges on the existence of specific jurisdictional facts, such as a valid construction contract and a legitimate payment claim. If an adjudicator errs in establishing these facts, it can lead to jurisdictional errors that may invalidate the entire adjudication process and any subsequent determination. This blog post delves into the nuanced and multifaceted challenges surrounding the jurisdiction of adjudicators, offering insights into the strategic considerations and potential pitfalls that parties must navigate in the adjudication process. …

Exploring the challenges relating to the jurisdiction of statutory adjudicatorsRead More »

Construction Industry, Construction Law, Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

Judicial Decisions Concerning Expert Evidence in Adjudication

By Dr Samer Skaik

In the realm of construction disputes, expert evidence plays a pivotal role in shaping the outcomes of litigation and arbitration. Traditionally, expert witnesses are engaged by parties to analyze facts, form opinions, and present conclusions that can influence the decision-making process of a tribunal. However, the growing use of expert witnesses in statutory construction adjudications, especially for large and complex payment claims, has introduced new challenges. Unlike the more extended timelines in litigation and arbitration, adjudicators in construction disputes often operate under severe time constraints—typically just 10 business days. This accelerated process leaves little room for the thorough examination of expert evidence, such as cross-examinations or detailed meetings with experts, which can complicate the adjudication process. …

Judicial Decisions Concerning Expert Evidence in AdjudicationRead More »

Construction Law, Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

The Evolution of Judicial Review of Adjudication Determinations

By Dr Samer Skaik

The judicial review of adjudication determinations under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) has evolved significantly over the years, reflecting a shifting legal landscape and its impact on the construction industry. This evolution, shaped by landmark cases and legislative intent, has had far-reaching implications for the adjudication process. …

The Evolution of Judicial Review of Adjudication DeterminationsRead More »

Construction Law, Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

The Court’s Approach When Intervening in Adjudication

By Dr Samer Skaik

The intersection of adjudication and judicial intervention in construction disputes presents a complex legal landscape, often necessitating the use of injunctions to address specific issues. This post provides an in-depth exploration of the court’s approach when intervening in adjudication, drawing insights from recent legal cases and judicial interpretations. …

The Court’s Approach When Intervening in AdjudicationRead More »

Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

Legal considerations in the operation of security of payment legislation

By Dr Samer Skaik

The Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment (SOP) Act in New South wales is a crucial piece of legislation that impacts the Australian construction industry. This Act holds significant implications for contracting parties, civil proceedings, judicial intervention, and the overall resolution of payment disputes. In this post, we will delve into the key provisions of the SOP Act and the impact it has on various aspects of construction contracts. …

Legal considerations in the operation of security of payment legislationRead More »

Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

Adjudication Determinations and Fees under Security of Payment Legislation

By Dr Samer Skaik

The determination made by an adjudicator holds significant weight in resolving payment disputes within the construction industry. Understanding the legal framework and implications of adjudication determinations is essential for all stakeholders involved in construction projects. …

Adjudication Determinations and Fees under Security of Payment LegislationRead More »

Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

Functions of ANAs and Adjudicators Under Security of Payment Legislation

By Dr Samer Skaik

In the construction industry, the role of Authorised Nominating Authorities (ANAs) and adjudicators is pivotal in ensuring the timely and fair resolution of payment disputes. Let’s explore the key functions and powers of ANAs and adjudicators under the Security of Payment legislation in NSW and other jurisdictions that follow its model. …

Functions of ANAs and Adjudicators Under Security of Payment LegislationRead More »

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

Navigating the Adjudication Process under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW)

By Dr Samer Skaik

The adjudication process, governed by the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW), plays a crucial role in ensuring the speedy resolution of payment disputes within the construction industry. Let’s delve into the intricate details of this process and the key considerations for both claimants and respondents: …

Navigating the Adjudication Process under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW)Read More »

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

How to Approach Security of Payment Claims in Construction Contracts under the New South Wales Model?

By Dr Samer Skaik

In the construction industry, ensuring timely and fair payment for work done is crucial for the smooth functioning of projects. Understanding the statutory right to progress payment and the adjudication mechanism outlined in the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) is essential for construction professionals to effectively manage security of payment claims. Here’s a practical guide on understanding how to approach security of payment claims: …

How to Approach Security of Payment Claims in Construction Contracts under the New South Wales Model?Read More »

Construction Law, Contract Administration, Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

Understanding the Features of Security of Payment Legislation in Australia and Singapore

By Dr Samer Skaik

In the realm of construction, ensuring timely payments and fair resolution of disputes is crucial for the smooth functioning of projects. Payment disputes, if not managed effectively, can lead to delays, strained relationships, and costly litigation. To address these challenges, jurisdictions like Australia and Singapore have implemented robust security of payment legislation. Let’s delve into the intricacies of this legislation, its features, criticisms, and its role in maintaining financial stability within the construction industry. …

Understanding the Features of Security of Payment Legislation in Australia and SingaporeRead More »

Construction Law, Project Management, Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

Unravelling Complexity: Towards a More Accessible Adjudication Process for Low-Value Claims

By Dr Samer Skaik and Ali Alkhatatneh

Low-value claims adjudication has become an increasingly intricate process, particularly for small subcontractors and individuals lacking legal expertise. This post delves into key factors influencing complexity in low-value claims adjudication, as outlined in our recent academic article commended in the 2023 Brooking Prize by Society of Construction Law Australia.

…

Unravelling Complexity: Towards a More Accessible Adjudication Process for Low-Value ClaimsRead More »

Construction Industry, Construction Law, Security of Payment, Statutory Adjudication

How to use the Security of Payment Legislation to recover or reject progress claims

By Dr Samer Skaik

The Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment legislation (SoPA) is a vital legal framework for contractors and subcontractors in the construction industry, particularly for the recovery of progress payments. Understanding and effectively utilizing this legislation can safeguard the financial health of businesses and ensure the smooth progression of construction projects. The purpose of this post is to offer a brief guide on navigating the Security of Payment legislation, highlighting its importance and providing practical steps for contractors and subcontractors to effectively manage and recover progress payments.

…

How to use the Security of Payment Legislation to recover or reject progress claimsRead More »